What is the Difference Between Refacing and Resurfacing Cabinets?

Cabinet Refacing vs Cabinet Resurfacing

Many homeowners want to update their kitchen’s appearance without the high cost of a full renovation. Two popular options often emerge: cabinet refacing and cabinet resurfacing. People frequently use these terms interchangeably, but they describe very different processes with unique outcomes, costs, and timelines. Understanding the distinction is crucial for making an informed decision that aligns with your budget and aesthetic goals. One method gives your cabinets a completely new look, while the other simply refreshes their current appearance.

This article clearly explains the difference between refacing and resurfacing cabinets. We will examine each process in detail, from the materials used to the labour involved. You will learn about the specific steps professionals take for both refacing and resurfacing. We will also compare the costs, project durations, and the overall impact each option has on your kitchen. By understanding these key factors, you can confidently choose the best method to revitalize your space and achieve the kitchen you envision. This knowledge helps you plan your project effectively and avoid unexpected expenses or disappointments.

What is Cabinet Refacing?

Cabinet refacing is a cosmetic update that dramatically changes the look of your cabinetry without altering its structure. This process involves keeping the existing cabinet boxes, or frames, while completely replacing the visible exterior parts. A professional begins by removing all the old cabinet doors and drawer fronts. They then prepare the surfaces of the cabinet boxes for a new finish. This preparation ensures the new material adheres properly for a long-lasting, seamless look.

Next, the professional applies a new veneer to the cabinet boxes. This veneer can be real wood, laminate, or thermofoil, and it matches the new doors and drawer fronts you have selected. Once the veneer is in place, new, custom-made doors and drawer fronts are installed. The project is completed with new hardware, including hinges, knobs, and pulls. The result is a kitchen that appears to have brand-new cabinets. You get a completely different style and colour without the disruption or cost of a full cabinet replacement.

Click here for more information about kitchen cabinet refacing
Related Article: How Long Does Cabinet Refacing Last?
Related Article: Does Cabinet Refacing Include Painting?

Process, Cost, and Timeline

Understanding the core differences between refacing and resurfacing helps you select the right option for your project. The primary distinctions lie in the process itself, the overall cost, and how long the project will take to complete. Each factor directly impacts your budget and the level of disruption in your home. Evaluating these aspects will clarify which method best suits your specific needs and expectations for a kitchen update.

The Renovation Process

The processes for refacing and resurfacing are fundamentally different. Refacing is a replacement project. It involves removing and discarding old doors and drawer fronts, applying a new skin or veneer to the cabinet boxes, and then installing brand-new components. This requires precise measurements and skilled installation. Resurfacing is a restoration project. It keeps all existing cabinet parts. The work focuses entirely on surface preparation and the application of a new finish, such as paint or stain. It is more labour-intensive in terms of prep work like sanding and cleaning.

Cost Comparison

Cost is often a deciding factor for homeowners. Cabinet refacing is more expensive than resurfacing. The higher price reflects the cost of new materials, including custom-made doors, drawer fronts, veneers, and hardware. Professional labour for this more complex installation also adds to the total expense. Resurfacing is a much more budget-friendly alternative. Its primary costs are for supplies like paint, primer, and sandpaper, along with labour. Many homeowners with some experience choose to resurface cabinets as a DIY project, which reduces costs even further.

Project Duration

The timeline for each project also varies. Professional cabinet refacing is surprisingly fast. Once the new doors and materials are ready, the installation typically takes only two to four days to complete. Resurfacing, especially as a DIY project, can take longer. The process requires significant time for cleaning, sanding, and priming. You must also account for the drying time between each coat of primer and paint, which can extend the project over a week or more. A professional can complete a resurfacing job more quickly, but it still often requires more on-site time than refacing.

Pros and Cons of Cabinet Refacing

Cabinet refacing offers a substantial transformation for your kitchen. This process gives you the look of brand-new cabinets for a fraction of the cost of a full replacement. However, it is important to consider both the benefits and the drawbacks before committing. Refacing is an excellent solution for many situations, but it is not the perfect choice for every home or budget. Evaluating these points helps determine if refacing aligns with your renovation goals.

• Dramatic Transformation

  Refacing provides a completely new look. You can change the wood type, colour, and door style, transforming a dated kitchen into a modern space.

• Increased Home Value

  Because it looks like a full cabinet replacement, refacing can add significant value to your home. It is a powerful update that appeals to potential buyers.

• Material Durability

  The new doors, drawer fronts, and veneers are high-quality, factory-finished materials. They are built to resist wear and tear, ensuring a long-lasting, durable finish.

• Less Disruption

  Refacing is much less disruptive than a full cabinet tear-out. Your kitchen remains functional for most of the project, which is typically completed in just a few days.

• Higher Cost

  The main disadvantage is the cost. Refacing is significantly more expensive than resurfacing because you are paying for new, custom-built components and skilled labour.

• Fixed Layout

  Refacing does not allow you to change your kitchen’s layout. You are working with the existing cabinet configuration, so any functional issues with the current design will remain.

Pros and Cons of Cabinet Resurfacing

Cabinet resurfacing, or painting, is the most affordable way to give your kitchen a fresh new look. It is a popular choice for homeowners on a tight budget or those who enjoy DIY projects. Like any home improvement option, it comes with its own set of advantages and potential downsides. Understanding these factors is key to deciding if a new coat of paint is the right solution for your cabinets and your lifestyle. This method is effective but requires careful consideration of its limitations.

• Cost-Effective

  Resurfacing is the most budget-friendly option. The low cost of paint and supplies makes it an accessible update for almost any homeowner.

• DIY Friendly

  With patience and attention to detail, a homeowner can achieve a beautiful finish. This allows you to save money on professional labour costs.

• Quick Colour Update

  Resurfacing is the fastest way to change your kitchen’s colour scheme. You can easily embrace new trends or refresh your space with a bright, new colour.

• Environmentally Conscious

  This method produces minimal waste. You are reusing all of your existing cabinet components, making it an eco-friendly choice compared to replacement or refacing.

• Limited Style Change

  Resurfacing only changes the colour. You cannot change the style of your doors or drawer fronts. If you dislike the current design, painting will not solve that problem.

• Durability Questions

  A painted finish is generally less durable than a factory-applied finish. It can be more prone to chipping, scratching, and wear over time, especially in a high-traffic kitchen.

Making the Right Choice for Your Kitchen

Choosing between refacing and resurfacing cabinets depends entirely on your specific goals, budget, and the current condition of your kitchen. The key difference between refacing and resurfacing cabinets is simple: refacing replaces the “face” of your cabinets for a new style, while resurfacing refreshes the existing surface with a new finish. Each path offers a valid way to improve your kitchen without the expense of a complete remodel. To make the best decision, you must assess what you truly want to achieve with your renovation project.

You should choose cabinet refacing if your cabinet boxes are structurally sound, but you want a major style transformation. It is the perfect option if you desire a different door style, such as moving from a traditional raised panel to a modern flat panel or shaker style. Refacing delivers the high-impact look of a brand-new kitchen at a mid-range price point. Conversely, you should choose cabinet resurfacing if you are happy with your current cabinet style and layout. This is the ideal choice for a budget-conscious update focused solely on changing the colour. It is a cost-effective way to brighten a dated space or align it with a new design theme. Ultimately, your choice will shape your kitchen’s future look and function.